|
Is there an Intel vs AMD war? |
Why an Intel processor over an AMD (Advanced Micro Devices) processor?
There are a few
reasons. Price isn't one of them. One is the leading edge of development in the
micro/nana technology is at Intel. AMD does do research and development but they
lag behind Intel in most respects. The race does not have an end in sight but
one that has lost a contestant, Motorola.
Intel vs AMD
AMD was brought into the processor manufacturing business by Intel back in
the 1980's. Intel could not keep up with the demand for the 8086/8088 processors so
instead of farming it out overseas they farmed it out to AMD. Unfortunately there was a suit
by Intel against AMD over the 286 and 386 processors claming that AMD reverse
engineered the processor to design their versions of the processor. That is
history this is now.
AMD seems to have a slight advantage when it comes to speed, this however
has a draw back, a very large draw back - HEAT. All AMD processors will run at a
higher operating temperature than a comparable Intel processor. (See the
footnote below).
Heat has a detrimental effect on devices regardless of who manufactures them.
Even with more than adequate cooling the AMD processor will not last as long as
an Intel processor. The cost difference between the two processors will not
compensate for the increase in your electric bill, the increase in power consumption
to drive the processor means an increase in your power bill.
From a personal view point as a computer repair tech and systems admin I have
seen AMD processors fail.
Back in the 1950's there was a saying about being Nuked: "Glow in the
Dark!"
This applies to an AMD? processor; the power consumption on AMD processors is
higher than Intel? processors, thus the higher operating temperature and with
out massive heat sinks and cooling they will fail and do...
At one time I had the responsibility for over 150
servers
in a Data Center. The company I worked for insisted on Intel systems. There are always
mavericks in all walks of life. I inherited the support for five servers that
were AMD systems, over about four years I watched them die off, two actually
melted the heat sinks to the processors. One I am not sure if the processor or
the power supply killed it, it caught fire.
There is an old axiom: "Buy cheap, Get cheap."
If you buy an AMD system today you will be buying another one in the near
future.
Then again AMD may figure out how to obtain their high clock speed with out
consuming so much power that the heat sink glows in the dark.......... maybe.
I explain why AMD processors run so much hotter (and will continue to do so) in my new book in the section on Overclocking ...
Self Computer Repair Unleashed! 2nd Edition
Manual.
You will find troubleshooting cpu's
here...
|